No wonder he hated Kubrick's movie.
Since I was giving Stephen King another chance, why not go after my favorite horror movie, The Shining next? I had always heard that he hated it, but reading about the novel without actually reading it gave me the sense that it wasn't that bad of an adaptation... ...and it wasn't, at it's most basic level. A flawed father with a drinking problem, a kid with supernatural abilities, an evil Hotel... they are all there in the movie, but the book is so much different. In the Book the House is undeniably an evil entity. It has a personality, it knows it wants Danny as food and it knows how to hit Jack Torrance were it needs to.
And King being an alcoholic, at the time, just how bad alcohol had driven Jack Torrence's life was almost completely lost in the movie. Here, there was more than simply harming Danny that got him to get clean. And as the House starts driving him nuts we get a more intimate look at his thought process. How badly he needs a drink. How a drink would make everything more tolerable. And the more and more that the House pushes him, he starts devolving back into his habits back when he was a drinking, down to the pills he took for the hangovers. I was amazed at how well Jack was written, and how incredibly engaging his loss of sanity was up until the point that the House decided to take possession of his body itself because, at the end of the day, Jack loved his family.
And Wendy is a completely different character. She is not a scaredy, meek woman, but she is much more proactive in the events. She tries to protect Danny much more, and tries to take steps to protect her family from the house much earlier. In fact, Kubrick said that a 'strong woman like Wendy would've left Jack' as his excuse for changing her personality... but that's wrong. Wendy has no choice, it's either staying with Jack, who has promised he will change(and does) or going back to her abusive mother who is belittling her all the time. She really had no good choice, and at least Jack was promising to change.
The Shining was a brilliant book. I still prefer the movie, it's a classic, but the book is just as fantastic, albeit in a very different way. So yeah, I understand why King hates it, but both are fantastic pieces of horror.
10

No comments:
Post a Comment