Naming shenanigans.
I had never heard about Earthsea before, and I was all the more unfortunate for it! I randomly discovered it one day via one guy ranting about JK Rowling, so I said... y'know what? Let's give it a chance. And it was glorious.As the books go along, they certainly grow darker and darker, in the third one we've got a world going amiss because one guy decided he didn't want to die. I found it so interesting how this story is tie to Ged's first adventure, and to be fair, Ursula found a way to weave the events from that book into the next stories, even if Ged's role diminished by the book. And how cool is it that if you also include the short stories, we get to follow Ged from his very birth to his death! But I digress, you thought the third book sounded dark? Then we get child rapes and disfigurement. It'd be bleak if only Tenar wasn't so driven to make Tehanu, the child victim in question, thrive. Man, I love Tenar. Much like we follow Ged's birth to his death, and he starts taking more of a supporting role for other heroes, we also see Tenar go from a precocious kid raised in a very bloodthirsty society to a very down-to-earth old woman who's willing to fight for what's right.
And then there's Tehanu, Tehanu was a lovely character too, much more mystical, but I loved her being adopted by Tenar, and how this poor victim of the evil that men do manages to come out of her shell and fulfill her true destiny.
And I didn't even mention the very best piece of lore: The True Names. Ursula came out with the brilliant idea that everything in the world, even people, have names and have TRUE names. Magic is done by using their True Names, because knowing something or someone's True Name is to understand its nature and thus bend it to your will. And because True Names are the True Nature of things, one cannot lie if they use the True Names of things.... except Dragons, because Dragons are magic... and... and well, Ursula develops the nature between Magic and Dragons later on. It's amazing stuff. It's an idea so good that it's been borrowed by other works, such as Eragon. Eragon even has Elves being the only ones who know how to 'lie', by twisting stuff, using true names.
And lastly, Harry Potter. Ursula made a scathing comment about how JK Rowling should've at least mentioned that Earthsea inspired her. I'm sorry, but, Ursula, baby, Harry Potter IS Hogwarts. While the Wizards' School in Earthsea is almost tertiary to the story. Ged's years as a student are almost glossed over in three chapters, and by book two he is already the headmaster. Later on the different teachers do make appearances in the stories, but the classes at the school don't really matter, nor the interpersonal relationships between the students. Sure, Ged has a pseudo-bully too in Book I, but it's completely different from Malfoy. Complaining about this is like claiming that because you wrote about the first wizard shooting a fire ball everyone should say that you inspired them.
Oh, and adaptations... poor Ursula couldn't catch a break. Ghibli Jr's adaptation whitewashes everyone, turns Tehanu's horrible burns into a pink spot on her face and makes a pastiche out of a few stories. It's garbage. The live action adaptation also whitewashes everyone. Garbage, both of them.
In conclusion, Earthsea is fantastic and everyone should read it.
10

No comments:
Post a Comment