Best narrator in town.
A few years ago I watched A Series of Unfortunate Events with my ex and I adored it. The story and characters were very quirky, and the Narrator was something else, regularly breaking the fourth wall to engage with the viewers. I knew I was going to love the books, it's just that I hated having to buy 13 books one by one. And then I found a bookset... As per usual, light spoilers ahead.So, the Narrator is what makes these books glorious. Constantly breaking the fourth wall to make jokes, just like in the show, or to make funny examples to convey ideas...or sometimes playing with the book's format, the Deja Vu chapter really got me, I thought there was an issue with my book! To think that I blindly despised this books when I came across them when I was a child. I know for a fact that I would've adored them had I given them a chance.
I remember feeling like each book was getting better than the last, although... I'd say The Austere Academy was my favorite one, because it introduced the Quagmire Triplets and The Misserable Mill the one I disliked the most.
And it's crazy, because the concept behind The Misserable Mill is so interesting! Violet, the inventor, has to investigate, Klaus' role, while Klaus has to invent something! But why it doesn't work: While the books are pretty 'cartoony', with Sunny tooth acrobatics and everything, Klaus' invention makes no sense. Gum doesn't work that way. You can't use it like a fishing rod. It's 100% impossible and it's the most unrealistic thing the book does. I can't suspend my disbelief that much. Thus, it's one of the very few things the show did better... although at the cost of having Klaus and Violet swapping roles.
That said, one little thing I loved about the show, that isn't in the books, is that when Dewey is murdered... he tells the Baudelaire children that it's not their fault. It was such a Dewey thing to do!
My favorite moment is in the Penultimate Peril, when Kit's sister tells the Baudelaires how much they've grown! For example, the series really downplays how important Klaus' reading skill is, no wonder I thought it was so lame, but here Kit tells him that he isn't just a kid that likes reading... he is a researcher! And how Sunny can walk and almost speak now, it was so beautiful!
Yeah, the books are fantastic. The Netflix Adaptation is pretty good, the casting is perfect and what not, they made Lemony work in a show and it's kinda nice how they added the VFD from the start... but the books are superior in every way that matters.
8.5






